A. Introduction of Varistor
A Varistor is made from ZnO grains and metal oxide (or polymer)[1]. When Varistor is switched off, it works on open status. The protected I/O port will still work well under normal condition. When ESD pulse applies on protected I/O port and it’s voltage is higher than the breakdown one of Varistor, the turn-on resistance of Varistor will become very small in order to pass the ESD pulse current to ground. So, the electrical system can be protected.
B. Introduction of TVS (Transient Voltage Suppresser) and TVS Array
B.1 TVS
A TVS is made from silicon material and its breakdown voltage of PN junction can be adjusted by silicon process condition. A TVS can be distinguished between uni-directional component and bi-directional one from I-V curves. Under normal condition, the TVS turns off and protected I/O port will still work well. When ESD pulse applies on the protected I/O port and its voltage is higher than the breakdown one of TVS, the TVS will work at breakdown region and clamp the ESD pulse voltage to protect the electrical system.
B.2 TVS Array
The equivalent circuit of 4-channel TVS array in SOT23-6L package is shown in Fig1(a). In Fig. 1(b), the OM (Optical Microscope) picture shows that there is only one chip in the SOT-23-6L package. In other words, several ESD protected I/O ports can be integrated in a small chip by layout design.
A portable device should has the follow qualifications: light weight, thin thickness, and small size. For this reason, the size of PCB (Print Circuit Board) is getting smaller and smaller. Because the space of PCB is saved, TVS Arrays are always used in the small size of PCB in order to help designer to overcome system level ESD issues.
C. TVS Array vs. Varistor
Both of TVS Array and Varistor are always used for system ESD protection design. Although they are used in the same way, the electrical characterization of TVS Array is much different from that of Varistor. The electrical parameters of TVS Array and Varistor are shown in the Table I. From Table I, it shows that the response time of Varistor is about nanoseconds (~ 10-9 sec.), while the one of TVS Array is about picoseconds (~ 10-12 sec.). The response time of Varistor is slower than that of TVS Array. It shows also can know that the leakage current of TVS Array is between 0.1nA to 1uA, while the one of Varistor is between several to hundreds uA. The leakage current of Varistor is higher than that of TVS Array. Varistor cannot be applied for high speed I/O interface (such as USB 3.1 and HDMI 2.0) ESD protection because its capacitance is between hundreds to thousands picofarad. In contrast, the parasitic capacitance of TVS Array which can be adjusted by silicon process condition and layout design is no more than the recommend parasitic capacitance specifications of the high speed I/O interfaces and it makes the high speed I/O interface still work well. The recommend of parasitic capacitance specification of ESD protection devices for high speed I/O interfaces application is shown in the Table II. The I-V curves of TVS Array and Varistor measured by The TLP (Transmission Line Pulsing System) are shown in Fig. 2 saying that the breakdown voltage of TVS Array is much smaller than that of Varistor. Under the same condition of TLP current, the clamping voltage of TVS Array is less than that of Varistor.
Varistors are aging over time owing to pulse voltage (such as ESD pulse). When aging phenomenon happens, the electrical characteristics of Varistor is from bad to worse[2]. That will reduce the life time of Varistor. On the contrary, a TVS Array doesn’t have such problems.
D. Summary
The parasitic capacitance of TVS Array is smaller, so that it can be applied for high speed I/O interface (such as USB3.1 and HDMI 2.0) ESD protection. A TVS Array has shorter response time and lower leakage current and its breakdown voltage is lower than that of Varistor. The clamping voltage of TVS Array is also smaller than that of Varistor. The electrical characteristics of Varistor is from bad to worse owing to the aging issues. But, a TVS Array doesn’t have such problems.
-the-equivalent-circuit-of-4-channel-tvs-array-in-sot23-6l-package-uakg62.png)
Fig. 1 (a) The equivalent circuit of 4-channel TVS array in SOT23-6L package
-an-esd-protection-chip-of-4-channel-tvs-array.-fyysx2.png)
Fig.1 (b) An ESD protection chip of 4-channel TVS Array.
Reference
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Varistor
[2] Yang Haishan et al., " Aging analysis of ZnO Varistor under ten impulses, " Insulators and Surge Arresters, no. 6, pp. 88-91, Dec. 2015.