Back to list

High risk of latch-up caused by improper TVS device selection for USB Type-C2020/09/08

Abstract: With the development and improvement of the USB interface and protocol, more and more smart products adopt the USB Type-C as connection interface, which supports more diverse video, audio and data transmission with faster transfer speed. At the same time, the signal transmission is surely prone to be exposed to the interference of external power surges. For this reason, the use of TVS diode as surge protection should be more rigorous. However, if the user only pursues a TVS device with lower clamping voltage without taking into account other parameters such as its operating voltage, it may cause TVS the risk of latch-up issue resulting in the impact on the real-time communications of Type-C interface, or even the circuit damage due to EOS (electrical overstress) in severe cases.

 

 

To deal with the proper and efficient transient voltage surge protection in the interface of electronic products with complex signal lines and power lines, the addition of a TVS diode at the interface shall be the most effective protection solution.

 

 

A. What is USB Type-C?

As being a serial data connection interface, USB (universal serial bus) has the advantages of fast transfer speed, quick connection, easy-to-use contact form, support for hot-plugging, independent power supply, etc., and is widely used in various types of electronic devices. The USB interface has been defined to the latest USB 4 from the initial version of USB 1.0. Among them, the protocol of USB 3.1 still remains the most popular interface until today.

Unlike USB 2.0 which defined only two connector types (Type A and Type B), the protocol of USB 3.1 has three interface standards: Type-A (Standard-A), Type-B (Micro-B) and Type-C, and two transfer rates: USB 3.1 Gen1 and USB 3.1 Gen2. The Type-C connector has been widely adopted by many electronic products, such as smartphones, tablets and laptops, etc.

 

USB official specification

Previous name

Theoretical

maximum data rate

Marketing name

Release date

USB2.0

USB1.0

1.5Mbps

Low-Speed

January 1996

USB1.1

12Mbps

Full-Speed

September 1998

USB2.0

480Mbps

High-Speed

April 2000

USB3.2

USB3.1 Gen 1

5Gbps

Super-Speed USB

November 2008

USB3.1 Gen 2

10Gbps

Super-Speed USB 10Gbps

June 2013

USB3.2 Gen 2x2

20Gbps

Super-Speed USB 20Gbps

September 2017

USB4

USB4 Gen 3x2

40Gbps

USB4 40Gbps

September 2019

Table 1: USB versions

 

 

USB 3.2 Gen2x2 specification with Type-C connector can reach up to 20Gbps signal transfer rate and support high-speed charging with PD (power delivery) technology up to 20V/5A (100W) of power. Since Type-C increases not only the data transfer rate, but also power-transfer capability, to ensure that the data transmission will not be disturbed by power surges in practical applications and the stability of the power transmission, adding TVS protection at the interface becomes especially important.

 

Figure 1: USB Type-C Receptacle Pins

Figure 1: USB Type-C Receptacle Pins

 




B. What is Latch-up
Latch-up refers to a type of short circuit formed in an integrated circuit and is a parasitic effect generated in CMOS manufacturing process. The latch-up is produced by the N-P-N-P structure which is formed by the source of the NMOS, the p-substrate, the n-well and the source of the PMOS. When one of the bipolar junction transistors (BJNs) gets forward biased, it may form a positive feedback loop bringing up the latch-up effect.

 


 

Figure 2: N-P-N-P structure in CMOS

 

Figure 3: Equivalent circuit of CMOS latch-up
 
 
When the N-P-N-P structure of the SCR circuit is not triggered, both BJTs stay in cutoff state. The collector current is made up of the collector-to-base reverse leakage current with very small current gain, and latch-up does not occur at this moment. If some external disturbances appear causing the sudden increase of collector current in one of the BJTs to certain value, it will feed back to the other one and create the conduction of both BJTs by false triggering. A low impedance path will be formed between VDD and GND (VSS). Due to the positive feedback between these two transistors, an excessive current flow from VDD to GND continues to produce resulting in the creation of latch-up, even if the external disturbances disappear.
 
 
In the practical application of IC chips, the major reasons that create latch-up are as follows:
1. When the chip is operating, rapid change of the VDD voltage may cause latch-up.
2. When a transient surge event (such as ESD or power surge) occurs, the large current flowing in the CMOS circuit may lead to latch-up.
3. Unexpected change of power supply and GND voltage caused by circuit overload may trigger another BJT of SCR to create conditions for latch-up.
4. If a protection device with a snap-back voltage lower than 3.3V is applied on the signal line or power supply with operating voltage higher than 3.3V, the system may be seriously damaged by latch-up when above transient surge events occur.
 
 
There are many types of designs for TVS diodes in the market. The TVS diodes offered by Amazing Microelectronic Corp. are mainly designed for three specific areas: traditional semiconductor diode, N-P-N bipolar junction transistor (BJT) and SCR circuit. The characteristic curves of these three types of TVS diodes are as below:
 
 
 

Figure 4: TVS diode characteristic curves

 

 

In the USB Type-C protection circuit, if the TVS diode is not selected properly, such as applying a TVS diode for SCR circuit to the VBUS terminal or the CC pin line, the risk of latch-up events is more likely occur, as well as the potential latch-up hazard to the signal lines. The primary reason is that, when transient surges (such as ESD or power surges) are coupled onto USB interface, the voltage of external surge will be greater than the TVS breakdown voltage which results in the conduction of TVS diode. If wrong type of TVS diode is adopted on device, it makes the snapback voltage (Vsb or Vhold) lower than the normal operating voltage (Vbus) or the maximum voltage (VMAX) of data signal after current passing through the TVS diode, and the TVS diode will remain conducting even if the external disturbance goes away. In this case, the sudden increase of current leads to power supply voltage drop or interrupts normal signal transmission. Or even the TVS diode may be burned out and short-circuit, resulting in EOS damage to the device or entire circuit in the worse cases.
 
 
Normally USB Type-C interface is plugged and unplugged while the power is on, it is easy to be exposed to switching surges or lead to surge interference with ESD cable discharge. To reduce the possibility of latch-up in the practical application of TVS diode at USB Type-C interface, when choosing the TVS diode type, we must not only ensure that the VRWM (reverse working maximum voltage) applied to the TVS diode shall greater than circuit’s normal operating voltage or data signal’s VMAX, but also consider that, once the TVS diode is conducting, the lowest Vsb or Vhold of snapback TVS device should greater than the circuit’s maximum operating voltage after the snapback state.
 
 
C. Best TVS solution for USB Type-C interface
Due to more power and data lines at a complete USB Type-C interface, the TVS diode protection solutions recommended by Amazing Microelectronic Corp. can be divided into three categories according to the signal type: VBUS power protection, Tx/Rx data lines protection and D+/D-/CC/SBU data line protection.
 
1. Since USB Type-C supports PD fast charging protocol, the VBUS transmission voltages commonly used are 5V and 12V, and the maximum can be 20V. Therefore, a TVS protection solution with proper operating voltage shall be taken for VBUS protection, and also ensure that no latch-up events will occur while selecting a TVS diode with lower clamping voltage. The following table shows the ESD and EOS protection solutions recommended by Amazing Microelectronic Corp. for applying on the VBUS power line of USB Type-C:
 

 
Part No Application VRWM (V) VCL-ESD(V) @ 8kV VCL-Surge (V) @ 5A IPP(A) Package
AZ3105-01F Only for 5V VBUS 5 6 6.4 80 DFN1610P2E
AZ4507-01F Only for 5V VBUS 7 10 8.5 100 DFN1610P2E
AZ4510-01F For VBUS ≤ 10V 10 13 21 80 DFN1610P2E
AZ4512-01F For VBUS ≤ 12V 12 15 14.5 38 DFN1610P2E
AZ4520-01F For VBUS ≤ 20V 20 25.5 25.5 24 DFN1610P2E
AZ4307-01F For VBUS ≤ 7V 7 9.5 8.3 180 DFN2020P2E
AZ4310-01F For VBUS ≤ 10V 10 13 11.7 150 DFN2020P2E
AZ4712-01F For VBUS ≤ 12V 12 15 14.8 225 DFN2020P2E
AZ4715-01F For VBUS ≤ 15V 15 18 17 170 DFN2020P3E
AZ4718-01F For VBUS ≤ 18V 18 22 22 138 DFN2020P3E
AZ4724-01F For VBUS ≤ 20V 24 28 28 125 DFN2020P3E
 
 
 Table 2: TVS solution for Type-C VBUS 
 
 

 

2. As Tx/Rx lines are used for high-speed data transmission, we have to choose a low-capacitance ESD-protection TVS diode to prevent excessive capacitance that affects the signal integrity of USB Type-C interface. The followings are the protection solutions recommended by Amazing Microelectronic Corp. for Tx/Rx high-speed transmission lines: 

 

Part No

Channel #

VRWM (V)

VCL-ESD(V) @ 8kV

Capacitance (pf)

Package

AZ1043-04F

4 lines

3.3

10.5

0.45

DFN2510P10E

AZ1043-08F

8 lines

3.3

9

0.5

DFN3810P9E

AZ1743-04F

4 lines

3.3

9.5

0.4

DFN1308P5Z

AZ176S-04F

4 lines

1.5

4.3

0.29

DFN2510P10E

AZ5B8S-01F

1 line

1.5

5.5

0.18

DFN0603P2Y

 

 Table 3: TVS solution for Type-C TX/RX

 

 

 

3. Recommended TVS solutions for the protection of USB D+/D- data cable and auxiliary signals (CC and SBU wires):  

Part No

Channel #

VRWM (V)

VCL-ESD(V) @ 8kV

Capacitance (pf)

Package

AZ1045-04F

4 lines

5

12

0.5

DFN2510P10E

AZ1045-08F

8 lines

5

10.5

0.5

DFN3810P9E

AZ5425-01F

1 line

5

24

0.8

DFN1006P2E

AZ5515-02F

2 lines

5

10

0.8

DFN1006P3X

AZ5B85-01B

1 line

5

11

0.5

CSP0603P2Y

AZC099-04S

4 lines

5

11.5

1.0

SOT23-6L

AZC199-04S

4 lines

5

11

1

SOT23-6L

 

Table 4: TVS solution for Type-C D+/D-/CC/SBU

 

 

Reference:

[1]. USB official website: https://www.usb.org/

 

 

 

 

NextESD Testing: Advantage of TLP Testing, and Difference between TLP, HBM and IEC 61000-4-2 Tests