• Applications

  • Blog
  • ESD Test Methods of System Products

ESD Test Methods of System Products

2018/08/21

Introduction

Substance surface during some process, such as friction and static charge induced so called Static Charge. ESD (Electrostatic Discharge), which produce an electrostatic charge transfer between different potential of the objects. The generation of electrostatic discharge damage, mostly due to human factors, but it is difficult to avoid. Static electricity can accumulate in the human instrument even the product itself during manufacturing, assembly, testing, storage, and transportation process, it is easy to generate a discharge path so that products would damage by electrostatic discharge.   


The ESD damage to electronic products is the problem that not always easy to solved. Compared with other over-voltage events, ESD is a very fast transient pulse. Once electronic products damaged by electrostatic discharge, there will be some instability phenomena, such as a sudden abnormal function. Some products which are slightly damaged can be recovered again. Unfortunately, some destroyed seriously may cause permanent damage thus should be avoided.


Component-Level ESD

Usually depending on the different discharge mode, the component level electrostatic discharge can be divided into three modes: Human Body Mode (HBM), Machine Mode (MM), and Charged Device Mode (CDM).   


The three forms of electrostatic discharge to the semiconductor manufacturing process and assembly of electronic products are very important. Especially the human body mode is most widely injury problem to the electronic products (semiconductor element). The human body discharged mode is resulting from the static friction which is generated by human action, such as walking on the carpet. Because of the negative charge keep on positive shoes by rubbing the carpet, the human foot senses the positive charge; while, the negative charge store at the upper body. Consequently, a discharged path resulting in damaged to the electronic devices is generated when hand contact with the electronic products.   


The international regulatory requirements about the Human Body Mode-protection on electronic product become more stringent. Electronic components in semiconductor industry mostly have passed the electrostatic discharge test (standard ± 2000V). The equivalent model of the human body discharge mode is shown as figure1, the discharge waveform rise time mediator between about 5 to 10 nanoseconds, shown in figure 2. 8000 volts discharge will generate approximately 5.5 amps of peak current. However, electronic devices suffer worse electrostatic discharge conditions at the system-level ESD test. In general, the electronic products set-up on system seldom passes the system-level test even the elements can pass the component-level ESD test.


Fig. 1. The equivalent circuit model of the human body discharge mode.

Fig. 1. The equivalent circuit model of the human body discharge mode.

   

Fig. 2. The waveform of the human body discharge mode.

Fig. 2. The waveform of the human body discharge mode.


System-Level ESD

Today, international recognized standard about system-level ESD is IEC 61000-4-2. The equivalent model and discharge waveform of the standard are shown as figure 3 and figure 4. The rise time is set on 700ps to 1 ns and pulse duration is 60 nanoseconds. Capacitance of the system-level is 150pF and capacitance of the component-level is 100pF. Discharge resistor of the system-level and the component-level is 330 ohms and 1500 ohms. Compared with the Human Body Model, the energy electrostatic discharge generated at system level electrostatic discharge test status is more in the larger storage capacitor and smaller energy discharge resistor. For example, when the same discharge voltage of 8000 volts peak current generated by the system level will reach 30 amps, five times as much as the element level, we can see the system ESD destructive testing is clearly more serious. That is the main reason that why some integrated circuit products can easily pass the component-level ESD test but cannot pass the system-level ESD test.


Fig. 3. The equivalent circuit model of the standard IEC 61000-4-2.

Fig. 3. The equivalent circuit model of the standard IEC 61000-4-2.


Fig. 4. The discharge waveform of the standard IEC 61000-4-2.

Fig. 4. The discharge waveform of the standard IEC 61000-4-2.


To ensure the functionality of electronic products, the international manufacturers require OEM products must meet the requirements of the standard IEC 61000-4-2 ESD. In addition to component-level ESD test, the final products will continue testing system-level ESD test not only to ensure product reliability but also make the products enter the international market.


Test Method

Electrostatic discharge gun (ESD gun) which set by the standard IEC 61000-4-2 ESD test is used, as shown in Figure 5. This is NoiseKen produced a basic electrostatic gun (ESS-B3011), an equivalent circuit diagram is shown in Figure 6.   


Environment setting section, first at ambient temperature should be 15-35 degrees Celsius; humidity is maintained at 30 percent to 60 percentage pressures between 68-106 kPa. There have two test conditions which are contact discharge and air discharge.


Fig. 5. Electrostatic gun (ESS-B3011,NoiseKen).

Fig. 5. Electrostatic gun (ESS-B3011,NoiseKen).

Fig. 6. The equivalent circuit diagram of ESD gun.

Fig. 6. The equivalent circuit diagram of ESD gun.


Contact Discharge :

This test method is a simulation about electrostatic discharge phenomenon that occurs when metal tools come into contact with electronic products. In this test method, discharge head of electrostatic discharge gun using a pointed piece of metal. At the beginning of test, the metal head of electrostatic gun against the target point, the electrostatic discharge stress in the tested product by the pointed head. Contact discharge test is usually measured positive and negative 4kV, this test method permit positive and negative voltage test conditions is higher than 4kV.     Contact discharge can be further divided into direct discharge and indirect discharge. The indirect discharge mode of system-level electrostatic discharge test is shown in Figure 7. The set-up of discharge mode consists of wooden tables and the ground reference plane. An insulating pad is set on the desktop in order to isolate tested product and metal horizontal coupling plane. Horizontal coupling plate will pick two 470kΩ resistors connect to the ground reference plane. When the electrostatic gun stresses the horizontal coupling plate, electrostatic discharge can cause electromagnetic interference coupled into the tested electronic product.


Fig. 7. The indirect discharge mode of system-level electrostatic discharge test.


Fig. 8. The indirect discharge mode of system-level electrostatic discharge test.


Air Discharge :

This test method is a simulation about electrostatic discharge phenomenon that occurs when human finger contact with electronic products. In this air discharge test method, using eight millimeters (mm) discharge head (round) of electrostatic discharge gun. At the beginning of test, let the electrostatic discharge gun very close to the test point. Electrostatic discharge of the gun through the air discharge head of electronic products for non-contact discharge test. The contact discharge connector and air discharge connector of the electrostatic discharge gun are shown in Figure 8. Test voltage from a low voltage to a high voltage, usually measured positive and negative 8kV, this test method permit positive and negative voltage test conditions is higher than 15kV.  Electrostatic discharge system- level test levels of contact discharge and air discharge displayed in Table I. Discharge time at intervals of one second is at least 10 times for each polarity. The clarification of the tested results is specified in accordance with the influences of product function. It will be divided into four levels, including grade A (Class A), grade B (Class B), grade C (Class C), and grade D (class D), as shown in table II.


Class
Criterion
Result
A No abnormal phenomenon occurs during ESD stress
Pass
BAbnormal phenomenon occurs during ESD stress, but will recover automatically
Pass
CAbnormal phenomenon occurs after ESD stress, manual restart is needed
Pass/Fail
DHardware damage
Fail

Table I

Electrostatic discharge system- level test levels of contact discharge and air discharge


Contact Discharge
Air Discharge
Level
Test Voltage (kV)
Level
Test Voltage (kV)
1±2
1 ±2
2±4
2 ±4
3±6
3 ±8
4±8
4 ±15
X”
Special
X”
Special
X” is an open level.

Table II

Electrostatic discharge system- level test levels 


Criterion A: It means that the product can be fully functional before and after the normal operation of the test and during the test, without any abnormal phenomenon, completely free from the influence of ESD discharge, called Class A.   


Criterion B: It means that the function will be affected by ESD discharge during the test, but can automatically recover after the test, called Class B.   


Criterion C: It means that the function can be operated normally before the test. It will be affected by ESD discharge during the test, but cannot recover after the test. It must do re-set by the operator to reply function, this situation called Class C.   


Criterion D: It means that the product function can be operated normally before the test, but the test process is abnormal, although do re-set by the operator still cannot reply function, this product probably has a serious injury which belongs to fail, called Class D.


Conclusion

According to the international standard, the system-level ESD testing can ensure product reliability. Further, with the more advanced wafer manufacturing process. The IEC 61000-4-2 standard is subdivided into four hazard classes, as shown in Table III, namely 2kV, 4kV, 6kV and 8kV voltage through 330Ω resistor, based on the electrostatic discharge voltage. Today's electronic systems require passing electrostatic discharge voltage at least grade 3 or 4. In level 4, for example, the maximum ESD current up to 30 amps, more than 20 times the wafer stage electrostatic discharge current. If calculated according to the above electrostatic discharge protection standards, it is clear that even if the discharge occurs only once, will face the risk of catastrophic damage on the next generation of integrated circuits. Predictably component-level products to be more difficult through the system level electrostatic discharge test, and at the lower cost considerations, to protect electronic equipment without being damaged will be very difficult.     


In the past, system-level ESD test in the manufacturers are mostly zapping at the shell, as shown in Figure 8. In recent years, the products all have passed standard system by testing on the product shell. Unfortunately, many customers return damaged products were found burned phenomenon at input and output port terminals, which means that just hit the product shell is insufficient to ensure product reliability. Obviously, it should be further testing at the pin of signal line ports of products, as shown in Figure 9.   


As mentioned above, the input and output ports of the system products with ESD protection devices become one of the best solutions in recent years. External ESD protection element plays a very important part of the products. Because the input and output port of electronic products will providing an electrostatic discharge path into the integrated circuit. Inhibiting the electrostatic discharge before coupling into the circuit board is the most effective way. On the selection of the ESD protection devices, low clamping voltage and the short response time are needed. Such as transient voltage suppression diode (TVS), be able to achieve good protection and also protect the system product from instant pulse of electrostatic discharge damage.


Fig. 9. The ESD test at the pin of signal line ports of products.


Reference: 

1. EMC – Part 4-2: Testing and Measurement Techniques – Electrostatic Discharge Immunity Test, IEC 61000-4-2 International Standard, 2008. 

2. Consortium of ESD Protection Technology for Circuits and System

Sign Up

Send